Evidence for Excellence: Building a Toolkit of Actionable Measures to Support and Advance Teachers (2026)

Policy Brief
This policy brief makes the case and offers scalable recommendations for a multi-measure system that gives North Carolina teachers credible, actionable evidence of their practice to guide their professional growth, licensure, and advancement.
Policy Brief

Every teacher deserves to know how they are performing, and every student deserves a teacher who has the feedback and support to keep improving.

In most professions, people receive regular, structured feedback on their performance, and that evidence shapes how they grow and advance. Most North Carolina teachers do not: about three in five have no individual measure of their impact on student learning, and at the high school level, more than four in five do not. The state’s current evaluation tools were not built to fill that gap. Observation-heavy systems from earlier reform eras asked a single, ill-fitting tool to do too much, consuming principals’ time without producing feedback teachers could use or evidence that reliably distinguished strong performance from weak.

Decades of research point to a different model consisting of multi-measure systems that combine evidence of instructional practice, student learning, and student experience. Multi-measure systems are more reliable, fairer, and more useful than observation-only models for both professional growth and formal decision-making. And yet, a multi-measure system is only as useful as the feedback it produces: teachers need results they can act on and a clear path from feedback to improvement. A teacher near the top of the effectiveness distribution produces roughly three times the learning gains of a teacher near the bottom in a single year – variation current tools mostly cannot see, let alone address.

This brief recommends North Carolina build an evidence-based multi-measure system governed by one principle: the state sets a rigorous menu of measures, each validated for the specific purpose it will serve. Principals and team leaders use every available measure to support a teacher’s growth, and for career-impacting steps such as licensure and advancement, the teacher chooses which validated measures count. New measures begin as tools for professional feedback and inform career-impacting decisions only after an independent evaluation shows they meet the standard for that use.

RESOURCE LIBRARY

Related Resources & Programs

Select one of the options below to learn more about that aspect of our work.

Policy Brief

Principal Pay in North Carolina: Aligning Compensation Strategies with Student Success (2026)

BEST NC’s policy brief documents North Carolina’s efforts from 2016 to 2020 to dramatically increase and transform the principal pay structure, focusing on how this…

Event, Policy Brief

2026 North Carolina Education Innovation Lab Conference Data & Research Brief

This conference brief provides relevant background info, data, and research and was published to support conversations held at the 2026 North Carolina Education Innovation Lab…

Summary

TeachReadyNC: A Bold New Teacher Apprenticeship Initiative (2026)

TeachReadyNC is designed to disrupt the costly cycle of teacher turnover, giving students access to more experienced, more effective teachers, while creating an apprenticeship pathway…

Policy Brief

The New North Carolina Principal Fellows Program: Navigating North Carolina’s Bold School Leadership Strategy (2024)

This report builds upon BEST NC’s 2018 policy brief by examining the latest research and best practices around principal preparation, providing an update on the…